linebreaks is a blog


holler: mike//AT//linebreaks//DOT//com

Archive for the ‘Columns’ Category

“Creative Class,” or class (re)creation?

Thursday, November 5th, 2009

My latest print piece is out today. It was intended to be another, clearer - and hopefully less negative - piece inspired by the Creative Places and Spaces conference. But who knows? It mostly ended up being about Richard Florida.

When Florida speaks of the need to involve everyone in generating wealth, especially workers, it’s perfectly genuine.

But can’t we do better than “wealth”? He relates a conversation with an executive from Toyota, which was opening factories in the Midwest while the Big Three were shuttering theirs. “’We harness the creativity of each of the workers on our factory floor,’” the exec told Florida, who elaborates: “The workers themselves form teams; they improve the process themselves without an engineer telling them what to do.”

In other words, new responsibility flowed downward. But I’ll bet you clunkers to cash that the new profits still flowed upward. That’s “collaboration?” In my day we called it exploitation. And we said it over the telephone. And the phone had a cord.

I would very much like to like Richard Florida. Honestly. He occupies a somewhat undefined - and therefore potentially powerful - space. I’m just never sure who it is he thinks he’s speaking to; and call me old-school, but I don’t think you get to talk about some vaunted “creative class” until you’ve proven you can actually talk about class, period.

In one way, he reminds me of McLuhan: it seems as though he’d like to be working with activists, yet it’s mostly businesspeople who have any idea what to do with him. (The difference, of course, is no one ever had any idea what to do with McLuhan, even if they thought they did.)

Seeking defeat in victory

Thursday, August 6th, 2009

Rounding out my coverage of the 2009 city workers’ strike, a little screed on right-wing Councillors’ latest organized attempt to shit where they eat. Why? Because, hey, Mayor Miller has to eat there too.

The right lost yet another battle on Friday, July 31, when it failed to defeat the Miller-sponsored settlement with TCEU 416 and CUPE 79. But to the sink-the-mayor faction, the war is one of attrition.

The space for rational discourse shrank. The leftmost border of the reasonable shuffled right. And lefty columnists are now in the awkward position of having to defend the strike deal as progressive.

I’m not with the union, but I’ll take them over the alternative

Thursday, June 18th, 2009

In my column this week I try out the idea that in the middle of theglobaleconomiccrisis (has anyone named their band Global Economic Crisis yet? Is that still up for grabs?), protecting workers’ collective agreements becomes more important. Because apparently that’s become just so nutty that we need 900 words to make a case for it - considerably more than the current accepted wisdom, “ARGLE BARGLE GREEDY BASTARDS!!!!!”

“I’m not sure I buy into the idea that these times require concessions,” says Ferguson. “This is a crisis largely driven by the banks and bad credit, and I find it disingenuous that the city would ask its employees to bear the brunt of an economic situation not of their making.”

Certainly, a lot of other employees out there are thinking the same thing. One has to wonder: are complaints about civic workers expressions of outrage or just jealousy of workers who still have the power to stand up for themselves?